- Request each driver's MVR from their licensing authority, covering at least the preceding 12 months, in every state where they held a commercial motor vehicle operator's license or permit during the period.
- Read the record and judge whether the driver meets minimum safe-driving requirements or is disqualified — a separate, required step from the inquiry.
- Weigh three categories of evidence: federal or hazmat regulation violations, accident record, and motor vehicle operation violations, giving great weight to speeding, reckless driving, and DUI.
- Write a note with the reviewer's name and the date and store it in the driver's qualification file — no note means no proof of review.
- Track each driver's next due date on a roster.
Run four checks on every driver's record each 12 months: make the inquiry, review the record, weigh the evidence, and file a dated note. For carriers whose drivers hold a commercial motor vehicle operator's license or permit, federal rules require this cycle regardless of incidents.
Key takeaways
Why this matters to you
You put technicians in company vans every day. When one of them causes a crash, the first question anyone asks is whether you knew about their driving history. If you cannot produce a dated record showing you reviewed it, that gap becomes the story.
Federal rules make this simple and non-negotiable: at least once every 12 months, you must check each driver's record. You do not get to skip it because the driver is safe. You do not get to skip it because nothing happened last year. Each driver's 12-month clock runs from that driver's own last review date, not from the calendar year.
This post gives you four checks to run on that 12-month cycle. Each one maps to a specific part of 49 CFR §391.25, the federal rule on annual inquiry and review of driving records. Together they cover what you ask for, how you judge it, what evidence weighs on the judgment, and what you keep on file.
Who this is for
This guide is for owners and dispatchers who manage technicians driving company vans. If you run a plumbing fleet, an electrical crew, an HVAC outfit, or another service business with vans, this cycle applies if your drivers hold a commercial motor vehicle operator's license or permit.
It is not for motor carriers operating only under the exceptions in subpart G of Part 391. If you are unsure whether your operation falls under an exception, ask your insurance carrier or a compliance adviser before you skip this process.
The four checks in one pass
Here is the full annual cycle at a glance:
| Check | What you do | When in the cycle |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Inquiry | Request the MVR from the licensing authority | At the start of the 12-month window |
| 2. Review | Read the MVR and judge fitness to drive | Right after you receive it |
| 3. Evidence | Weigh violations, accidents, and regulation breaches | During the review step |
| 4. File | Write a dated note and store it | Immediately after the review |
Now let's break each one down.
Check 1: Make the inquiry to each licensing authority
The rule says you must "make an inquiry to obtain the motor vehicle record of each driver it employs." The inquiry goes to each driver's licensing authority — the state or jurisdiction where that driver held a commercial motor vehicle operator's license or permit during the time period being covered.
Two things trip people up here. First, the record must cover at least the preceding 12 months. An MVR pulled today that only shows six months of history does not satisfy the requirement. Second, if your driver held licenses in more than one state during the covered period, you need to inquire in each of those jurisdictions.
For van fleets, most drivers hold a standard state driver's license rather than a CDL. The inquiry is required only if your vans fall under the commercial motor vehicle rule, so confirm that with a compliance adviser. Check directly with your state's DMV or licensing authority on current fees and ordering procedures.
Practical tip: Set a recurring calendar reminder for each driver, staggered so you are not pulling all your MVRs on one day. If you hired a driver eight months ago, that driver's first annual review will come due twelve months from the hire date, which is four months from now.
Check 2: Review the record against safe driving minimums
Once the MVR arrives, you have a second, separate duty. The rule requires you to "review the motor vehicle record of each driver it employs to determine whether that driver meets minimum requirements for safe driving or is disqualified to drive a commercial motor vehicle."
The review is a judgment call, but it is not arbitrary. You are checking for two things:
Does the driver still meet minimum requirements for safe driving? This looks at the pattern of violations and incidents on the record over the covered period.
Is the driver disqualified? Disqualification for commercial motor vehicle operation is governed by a separate regulation (§391.15), and you need to check the driver's record against whatever that rule requires.
Who performs the review matters. The person doing it should be someone with authority to make a keep-or-remove decision — typically the owner, safety director, or dispatch manager. A bookkeeper who pulls the MVR and files it without reading it does not satisfy the review requirement.
Different motor carriers set different internal standards for what counts as a failing record. Ask your insurance carrier what their loss-control department recommends, since their experience with claims often gives practical guidance.
Check 3: Weigh the evidence the regulation requires you to consider
This is where the review gets specific. The rule names three categories of evidence you must consider.
First: any evidence the driver violated federal safety regulations or hazardous materials regulations. For van fleets, this mostly means evidence of violations picked up during roadside inspections or found in prior employment records.
Second: the driver's accident record. Any accidents over the covered period go into the review. Whether an at-fault accident weighs more than being rear-ended is a reasoned judgment you document.
Third: violations of laws governing motor vehicle operation. Here the regulation is emphatic: you must give great weight to violations like speeding, reckless driving, and operating under the influence of alcohol or drugs. The rule explains why — these violations indicate the driver has exhibited a disregard for the safety of the public.
A single speeding ticket is a conversation. A pattern of speeding tickets, a reckless driving charge, or any DUI is a different matter entirely. When you see those on an MVR, the regulation expects you to take them seriously.
How weight maps to action
A practical way to think about the evidence:
- Disqualifying: Anything that triggers disqualification under the applicable rule. Immediate removal from commercial driving duties.
- Great weight: Speeding, reckless driving, DUI. These signal disregard for public safety and demand a documented decision, not a pass.
- Standard weight: Other moving violations and at-fault accidents. Considered in pattern and context.
- Informational: Non-moving violations, administrative issues. Noted but rarely decisive on their own.
Your judgment, documented and reasoned, is what counts.
Check 4: Write the note and file it
The rule closes with a documentation requirement: "A note, including the name of the person who performed the review of the driving record required by paragraph (b) of this section and the date of such review, shall be maintained in the driver's qualification file."
That note needs two elements: who did the review and when they did it. Beyond those two elements, record what you decided and why. If a driver's record raised concerns but you decided to keep them driving, write down the reasoning. If you pulled driving privileges, write that down too.
The note goes in the driver's qualification file. If your state has its own requirements for where driver records live, confirm with your state's transportation or motor vehicle agency how to align the federal file with any state-level filing rules.
No note, no proof of review.
Running the cycle so it never slips
Each driver's 12-month clock is separate, so a fleet of twelve drivers can have twelve different due dates.
The clustered review. All drivers reviewed in December because that is when the calendar reminder fires. It works, until December is busy and the reviews slip into January. Now you have missed the 12-month window for some drivers.
The hire-date gap. A driver hired in March gets their first review in March. But if the person running the reviews only thinks in calendar years, that driver's next review may slip past March, and the gap between reviews can then exceed 12 months.
The inquiry-without-review. The MVR gets ordered and arrives, but sits unopened. The inquiry happened; the review did not. Both are required.
A simple fix: build a driver roster with a "review due" column. Every time you complete a review for a driver, set the next due date 12 months forward. Review the roster monthly. The drivers with the nearest due dates get attention first.
Illustrative example: one roster, two due dates
A fleet has 12 drivers. Driver A was reviewed 3 months ago, so the next review is due in 9 months. Driver B was reviewed 11 months ago and is due in 1 month. Sorting the roster by next due date puts Driver B first, so that inquiry goes out now.
What to do when a record comes back bad
If the review shows a driver is disqualified, act immediately: remove them from commercial driving duties and document the removal. How long before they can return depends on the disqualification rule itself.
If the review shows concerns short of disqualification — a pattern of speeding, a recent at-fault accident, a reckless driving charge — you have a documented decision to make. Options include additional training, a probationary period with closer monitoring, or reassignment to non-driving duties. Whatever you decide, write it down in the same note that records the review.
Building this into your operation
For a small van fleet, the annual driver record review can run on nothing more than a shared spreadsheet and a calendar. Larger fleets with dedicated safety staff may want a compliance platform. For vehicle-level tools, see fleet tracking vendor figures. Either way, the structure is the same: inquire, review, weigh, file — every 12 months, for every driver.
The drivers you put behind the wheel are your responsibility on the road. This annual cycle is how you prove you took that responsibility seriously.
Next step today: Open your driver list, write each driver's last review date beside their name, and set the next due date 12 months later. For a driver who has never been reviewed, count 12 months from the hire date.
Related guides: California needlestick log: 7 calendar days to record · Injury record copies: 2 rules, free first, fee after · Credit sale dates: 2 dates to record for each job.
Frequently asked questions
What if a driver's license was suspended during the year? The suspension itself goes into the review. Ask whether the suspension involved any of the violations the regulation flags for great weight — speeding, reckless driving, or operating under the influence of alcohol or drugs. If the suspension related to one of those, the review conclusion likely changes. Document what you find and the reasoning behind your decision.
Do I need to run this check if all my drivers hold regular state licenses, not CDLs? The rule covers drivers who hold a commercial motor vehicle operator's license or permit, so confirm with your insurance carrier or a compliance adviser whether it reaches your vans.
Can I review a driving record I already have on file instead of making a new inquiry? The rule requires an inquiry to obtain a record covering at least the preceding 12 months. A record you already have may not cover that window. Pull a fresh MVR to be safe, then run the review against it.
What happens if I miss the 12-month deadline for one driver? Make the inquiry and complete the review as soon as you realize the miss, and document both the review and the delay. The regulation sets the minimum cadence; catching up quickly and recording what happened is the best response. Repeated missed cycles across your fleet is a much larger problem than one late review.
Does the note have to be handwritten or signed? The regulation requires the reviewer's name and the date in a note kept in the driver's qualification file. An email you send to yourself with the date and your name, filed in the qualification folder, satisfies the letter of the requirement — though a more detailed note serves you better if questions arise later.