Motive's fleet fuel management page says: "How Motive fleet fuel management can help you save up to 13% on fuel."
The words that matter are "up to." That phrase sets a ceiling, not an average. The quote gives a maximum saving of 13%, without showing how many customers reached it. The quote does not tell you the typical result, so ask for it.
Ask three questions:
- What is the typical saving across customers, and what share of customers reached the top figure?
- What baseline is used? Last year's fuel for the same trucks, or a different period with different work?
- How long did the comparison run, and did anything else change, such as new trucks, new routes, or a new fuel policy?
Then run your own numbers. Take your last three months of fuel spend, annualize it, and multiply by 13%. That is the most the vendor's top figure could be worth to you. Compare that number with the yearly cost of the subscription, hardware, and installation. If the ceiling does not clear the cost, the fuel figure cannot justify the purchase by itself, whatever the average turns out to be.
Ask where the savings data comes from, too. Some systems read fuel from the truck's engine data, others depend on fuel card records or driver entries. Ask how each source is matched to your trucks. If your techs fill up at different stations, you want to know whether the report reads that as a saving, a cost, or nothing at all.
Ask also what kind of saving you expect. Savings from less idling, shorter routes, and fewer miles driven each have a different fix. If most of the saving comes from idling, the idling questions in section 5 matter most. If it comes from routing, you need to know whether dispatch can change routes during the day.
Scale matters as well. The same Motive page quotes a customer who says: "Last year we were spending around $110k/month on fuel, and sometimes it's higher." That is a large fleet's spend. A percentage saving on that base produces large dollar figures. The same percentage on your smaller bill produces a smaller number, so the case has to be built on your own spend, not someone else's.