Straight into the service manual page
WrenchQuarry
More

Idle equipment costs: federal rule usually caps at 1 year

WrenchQuarry Editorial Team · Published · 12 min read · How these guides are written

Idle equipment is any asset not earning its keep; federal contracts usually allow its cost for up to 1 year. A van parked between jobs, a tool bank that only one crew opens, a shop bay nobody has booked this month: all of these cost you money whether or not they move. The pricing question is not whether the asset is still. It is whether its cost keeps landing on the work you sell.

Key takeaways

  • Sort each asset as fully idle or partly used, because the federal rule treats the two differently.
  • Record the date each fully idle asset stopped earning work.
  • Track the idle share of each partly used asset over a set period.
  • Log the initiative you took on each idle asset, such as a rental listing or a sale quote.
  • Review every asset at least once a year and decide: use it, lease it, sell it, or keep it with a written reason.

What counts as idle

The federal cost rules for government contractors give useful words for sorting this out. They define "facilities" broadly: "Facilities means plant or any portion thereof (including land integral to the operation), equipment, individually or collectively, or any other tangible capital asset, wherever located, and whether owned or leased by the contractor." (FAR 31.205-17, Acquisition.gov)

A van is equipment. A tool bank is equipment. A shop bay is part of the plant or another tangible capital asset. The same wording covers all three, and it covers leased items as well as owned ones. A van on a lease is still a facility for this purpose.

The same section splits idle assets into two groups. The first is the completely unused asset. The rule says, "Idle facilities means completely unused facilities that are excess to the contractor's current needs." A van that never leaves the yard, or a spare tool bank nobody needs this quarter, falls here.

The second group is the partly used asset: "Idle capacity means the unused capacity of partially used facilities." A tool bank that works two days a week, or a shop bay used only in the mornings, has idle capacity for the rest of its time.

Keeping these two groups apart changes how you think about the cost. A fully idle van is mostly a yes-or-no question: is it still needed? A partly used tool bank is a question of how much of its time is empty, and that takes a measurement. Many owners blur the two together. They either write off a healthy asset or keep a dead one on the books for years.

Why idle costs pile up

Idle time looks harmless because nothing is being spent on it that day. The cost is still there, and it has to go somewhere. A plain example from managerial accounting shows how the bill builds. OpenStax's break-even chapter explains the basic idea: "The basic theory illustrated in Figure 3.3 is that, because of the existence of fixed costs in most production processes, in the first stages of production and subsequent sale of the products, the company will realize a loss."

The chapter then works an extreme case, which is useful precisely because it is extreme. It assumes fixed costs of $20,000, a sales price of $400 for each unit, variable costs of $250 for each unit, and no units sold. With no sales, the result is simple: "It would realize a loss of $20,000 (the fixed costs) since it recognized no revenue or variable costs."

The chapter ties that back to the cost picture: "This loss explains why the company's cost graph recognized costs (in this example, $20,000) even though there were no sales." That is the point for idle equipment. Fixed costs show up in the accounts whether the equipment works or sits. Insurance, storage, loan payments and depreciation on a van do not wait for the van to earn its keep. They keep running while the asset waits.

The chapter also shows the way back: "If it subsequently sells units, the loss would be reduced by $150 (the contribution margin) for each unit sold." In that example the $150 is the $400 price minus the $250 variable cost. Each sale chips away at the loss, so the business needs enough sales to cover its fixed costs before it breaks even.

Apply that to a shop with idle equipment. Each job you run has to carry part of the fixed cost of the assets that sit unused, not just the materials and labor on that job. A quote built only from direct costs leaves the idle cost uncovered, and the gap comes out of your own pocket. For one way to build cost parts into a quote, see Floor price for a one-off job: 3 cost parts. The textbook figures are not a benchmark for your business. Use the pattern, not the amounts.

The one-year limit

Here is the number owners usually ask about. The federal rule on idle facilities says: "Costs of idle facilities are allowable for a reasonable period, ordinarily not to exceed 1 year, depending upon the initiative taken to use, lease, or dispose of the idle facilities (but see 31.205-42)."

The rule and its definitions break down into the parts that matter for a van, a tool bank or a shop.

PointWhat the rule says
Asset completely unusedCompletely unused and excess to current needs
Asset partly usedThe unused share of a partly used asset
Usual time limitA reasonable period, usually capped at the one-year figure discussed above
What changes the clockThe initiative taken to use, lease or dispose of the asset
Test for idle capacityWhether the capacity was necessary or reasonable, and whether subletting, renting or sale could cut it

Three parts of the one-year sentence need attention. The quoted wording sets the usual ceiling, so that is the number to remember. "A reasonable period" means the year is a typical outer limit, not a guarantee that any idle cost is fine until the twelve-month mark. The third part is what you do during the idle period, and that changes how the rule applies. The sentence also points to another section, 31.205-42, which this post does not cover.

Be clear about scope. This rule governs which idle costs can be charged under federal government contracts. It does not set the terms for your van, your tool bank or your shop, and it is written for federal contract work, not for private jobs. Treat it as a reference point for how long idle cost is usually treated as reasonable. It is also a prompt to ask the same questions about your own assets: how long has this sat, and what am I doing about it?

Conditions that decide whether the cost stays in the price

The rule goes further than the time limit. Costs of idle capacity are allowable "provided the capacity is necessary or was originally reasonable and is not subject to reduction or elimination by subletting, renting, or sale, in accordance with sound business, economics, or security practices."

Read that as two tests. The first is whether the capacity was necessary, or reasonable to have, when you got it. Buying a van for work you could see coming is a different case from buying one on a guess that never materialized.

The second test asks whether you could cut the capacity. If the spare van could be rented out, the extra tool bank could be sublet to a neighboring shop, or the bay could be sold or leased to someone else, the cost is harder to defend as a necessary cost. The rule names three moves for that: subletting, renting and sale.

The phrase "sound business, economics, or security practices" is a judgment call. No list in the rule settles it for you. Where it applies to your business, you have to answer it yourself. Ask what a careful owner would do with the asset if it were their own money, and write the answer down.

The one-year line and these two tests work together. The time rule ties the allowable period to the initiative you take, and the capacity test asks whether the spare capacity could be reduced or eliminated by subletting, renting or sale. An asset that sits idle for a long stretch with no rental listing, no sale attempt and no decision on file gives the rule the least to work with. An asset you have actively tried to put to use or move on has a better record under the rule's logic, even if it sat for a while.

Set up a check for each asset

A rule is only useful if you can apply it. Start by listing every van, tool bank, shop bay and major piece of equipment you carry. For each one, note whether it is fully idle or partly used. The split in the rule makes that quick. A van either runs or it does not. A tool bank usually has some share of time when nothing is happening.

For fully idle assets, record the date the asset stopped earning work. That date is the starting point for the one-year figure. When an asset reaches the year mark without a use, a lease or a disposal decision, that is the signal to act, because the rule's usual ceiling has been reached. Do not wait for a renewal bill or a tax deadline to make the decision for you.

For partly used assets, track the idle share over a set period, such as a month or a quarter. You do not need the full calculation from the rule to get value out of it. Start with the time the asset could have worked. Take out the normal stoppages, such as repairs, setups, unsatisfactory materials and other ordinary delays. Then take out the time it was actually used. What remains is the idle part. Write the number down, even if it is rough.

Record the initiative. Note what you did about each idle asset: a rental listing, a sale quote, a request to another shop, a lease offer, or a decision to keep it with a reason. The rule ties the allowable period to that initiative, so the record is your evidence. An asset with a paper trail is far easier to explain than one you remember only as "we'll use it again."

Finally, set a review date. Once a year at minimum is the natural rhythm, matching the rule's usual ceiling. When the date comes around, make a clear decision for each asset: use it, lease it, sell it, or keep it with a written reason that says why the idle cost still belongs in your price.

Illustrative example: a spare van

Suppose a spare van costs $100 a month to hold, counting insurance, storage and depreciation. No job carries that cost in its quote, so your margin pays it each month the van sits. After a year with no rental listing, no sale quote and no decision on file, the cost is hard to defend. The same van, listed for rent in month two, has a clearer record of initiative, even if it sat for a while.

Trades and tool banks

Vans and tool banks are often bought as a bundle, and it is easy to treat the whole kit as one asset. A trade's kit is usually a mix of things used at very different rates. O*NET's description of electricians shows the range: they "Use a variety of tools or equipment, such as power construction equipment, measuring devices, power tools, and testing equipment, such as oscilloscopes, ammeters, or test lamps." (O*NET OnLine, 47-2111.00 Electricians)

That mix matters for idle cost. In one tool bank, a set of power tools may come out on most days, while a specialty testing kit sits in a drawer for weeks between the jobs that need it. If you measure idle time for the whole bank as one figure, the average hides the expensive part. Track the items that sit longest on their own line, and the decision gets much clearer. A testing instrument that has not left the bank in a year is a different question from a drill that goes out every morning.

The same logic applies to vans. A van that does daily runs is not idle in any sense that matters. A second van kept for peak weeks may be idle most of the year. For the depreciation side, see Service van depreciation: 2 common mistakes to avoid. Keeping the two in separate records stops the decision about the second van from being buried in the cost of the first.

Putting idle cost into the price

Before you quote, decide how much of each idle asset's cost you carry into your rate, and for how long. For the job-side cost lines, see Job cost sheet: 3 cost lines to total on every job. Write that decision down with its review date. A written number is easier to defend, to yourself and to a customer who asks why a rate looks high. It also stops old idle costs from riding along in your rate by default, long after the asset stopped earning its place.

Keep the break-even lesson in view as you do this. The textbook example showed that fixed costs stay on the books with no sales, and that each sale reduces the loss only by its contribution. For your business, the jobs you run this year need to carry the fixed cost of the equipment you own, including the parts that sit idle. If idle cost is not in the rate, it has to come from somewhere else, and that is usually your margin.

The one-year figure is a usual ceiling, not an automatic pass. An idle asset that has sat for a year with no action is in a weak position under the rule's own logic. An asset that has been actively offered for use, leased or sold stands on firmer ground. The question that matters is less about the calendar and more about what you did while the asset waited.

Today, list every van, tool bank and shop bay you carry, with the date each one last earned work. That short process will tell you which idle costs belong in your price and which ones should have left the books a long time ago.

Related guides: 3 cash budget figures to set before buying equipment · Job-cost comparisons: 3 checks across periods · Enter 3 fields on each equipment estimate line item.

Frequently asked questions

Does the one-year figure apply to private jobs?

No. The rule is written for federal contract work and does not set terms for private jobs.

What is the first step for a partly used tool bank?

Track its idle share over a set period, starting from the time it could have worked.

Does a rental listing count as initiative?

Yes, a rental listing is one example of initiative worth recording.

Sources

More field guides