Straight into the service manual page
WrenchQuarry
More

Insurance approval is not a determination: 3 points on cost

WrenchQuarry Editorial Team · Published · 11 min read · How these guides are written

Approval of an insurance program under FAR part 28 does not decide whether an insurance cost is allowable on federal invoices. Owners who bill federal or public contract work often treat an insurance approval as a finish line. The program is reviewed, a letter goes into the file, and the premium lands on the next invoice as if the question were closed. The Federal Acquisition Regulation does not work that way. Its insurance cost provision, found at FAR 31.205-19, treats approval and allowability as separate matters. This post covers three points on cost, then a checklist for invoice lines, a worked example, and the mistakes that cost owners the most.

Key takeaways

  • Treat program approval as a condition on the program, not as clearance for each invoice line.
  • Give every insurance line a category before you total the invoice.
  • Attach the contract clause or approval record to any required or approved coverage.
  • Gather four figures before you bill any self-insurance charge.
  • Take defect-correction coverage out of the billed amount.

Point 1: Approval does not decide allowability

The sentence that matters most in the provision is this one:

> However, approval of a contractor’s insurance program in accordance with part 28 does not constitute a determination as to the allowability of the program’s cost.

Approval asks whether the insurance program was set up in accordance with part 28. Allowability asks whether a particular cost can be charged on the contract. A program can pass the first test and still leave individual costs to be checked against the second. That is the core of the problem on many invoices: a line gets billed because the program was approved, and nobody asks whether the specific dollars in that line qualify.

The same provision also says, as a direct requirement, that "The contractor shall comply with (48 CFR) part 28." So the program has to fit a defined framework. Meeting that framework is a condition on the program. It does not settle what each premium, charge, or reserve on your invoice is worth to the government. Think of the approval as the door you walk through, not the review of every room behind it.

Owners blur these two questions for a practical reason. Insurance feels like fixed overhead. It appears as a few large entries in the accounts, and the billing system often groups those entries under a single heading. That grouping is easy to type and risky to bill, because the rule does not treat all insurance money the same way. Before you total anything, separate the approval record from the line-by-line question it does not answer.

Point 2: Each insurance line falls under its own rule

The provision does not put insurance into one bucket. Read against the quoted text, it separates costs by whether the coverage was required or approved under the contract, whether it is general business coverage, and whether the risk is held through purchased insurance or by the company itself. It also treats defect correction and government property coverage on their own terms.

The first category is the cleanest. The provision states: "(1) Costs of insurance required or approved pursuant to the contract are allowable." If a line falls here, the reference is what makes it defensible. Keep the contract clause or approval record attached to the line, so anyone reviewing the invoice can trace where the cost came from without asking you to reconstruct it from memory.

General business coverage is listed on its own. The provision names "(2) Any other coverage the contractor maintains in connection with the general conduct of its business." Because it appears as a separate item, do not assume it takes the same treatment as the required coverage just because both are insurance. A policy that protects the business in general is not automatically the same thing as coverage the contract requires or approves. Read the item, decide where it belongs, and write down why.

Defect coverage gets its own sentence: "(3) The cost of insurance to protect the contractor against the costs of correcting its own defects in materials and workmanship is unallowable." If an invoice line pays for protection against the cost of correcting the contractor's own defects, it does not belong in the billed amount under this provision. This is the category most likely to hide inside a general insurance total, so look for it by its purpose, not by its label.

Point 3: Self-insurance is measured against purchased insurance

The table below sets the quoted items side by side. Use it as a checklist for the lines on any invoice that touches insurance.

Insurance cost in the ruleWhat the rule says
Required or approved under the contractAllowable
Other coverage maintained for the general conduct of the businessListed as a separate item
Self-insurance charge plus administration expenses in excess of comparable purchased insurance, where purchased insurance is availableUnallowable (the excess)
Self-insurance charges for risks of catastrophic lossesUnallowable
Cost of insurance to protect against correcting the contractor's own defects in materials and workmanshipUnallowable
Approval of an insurance program under part 28Not a determination of allowability

Self-insurance is where the money is most often at stake, and the rule is more precise than a simple yes or no. Where purchased insurance is available, the provision says: "(3) If purchased insurance is available, any self-insurance charge plus insurance administration expenses in excess of the cost of comparable purchased insurance plus associated insurance administration expenses is unallowable."

Read that carefully. The removed amount is the excess over comparable purchased insurance, and the administration expenses sit on both sides of the comparison. The whole self-insurance charge is not removed when purchased insurance is available. Only the part beyond the comparison is. So the real work is the comparison itself. You need the self-insurance charge, its administration expenses, the cost of comparable purchased coverage, and the administration expenses that go with that purchased coverage. Without all four figures, you cannot say how much of the line is in excess.

Illustrative example: one self-insurance line

Suppose a self-insurance line carries a charge of 90 and administration expenses of 20. Comparable purchased insurance would cost 60, with 10 in associated administration expenses. Add the two self-insurance figures, add the two purchased-insurance figures, and subtract the second total from the first. The difference is the amount this provision makes unallowable. These figures are illustrative only and are not drawn from any real policy or invoice.

Catastrophic losses are handled differently. The provision states: "(4) Self-insurance charges for risks of catastrophic losses are unallowable (see 28.308(e))." That sentence has no comparison condition attached to it. For risks of catastrophic losses, the self-insurance charge is unallowable as written, and the cross-reference to 28.308(e) points you to the related part of the rule.

The provision also limits what government property coverage actually covers. It reads: "(C) Such insurance does not cover loss of Government property that results from willful misconduct or lack of good faith on the part of any of the contractor’s managerial personnel (as described in FAR 52.245-1(h)(1)(ii))." This is a statement about the coverage itself, not only about the cost. If an invoice bills for coverage of Government property, the provision says that insurance does not reach losses caused by willful misconduct or lack of good faith on the part of managerial personnel. Do not describe that coverage, on an invoice or in a cover note, as if it protected against those losses.

Read the table by outcome, not by label. Three of the rows say a cost is unallowable in some form, one says a cost is allowable, one says approval is not a determination, and one lists a separate category. The two self-insurance rows look similar but work differently. One removes only the excess over a purchased-insurance comparison, while the other has no such comparison attached. Mixing those two rows changes the amount billed, not just the wording of a note.

Check each line before it goes on the invoice

Run every insurance-related entry through the same sequence before you total the invoice. The steps below follow from the quoted provisions. They are a working order, not a substitute for reading the full rule.

  1. Give every insurance line a category from the table before you total the invoice. A line without a category is not ready to bill.
  2. For required or approved coverage, attach the contract clause or the approval record that supports it.
  3. For self-insurance, gather four figures: the self-insurance charge, its administration expenses, the cost of comparable purchased insurance, and the administration expenses tied to that purchased cover.
  4. For self-insurance charges tied to catastrophic-loss risks, flag the line as unallowable under the provision and cite 28.308(e) in the note.
  5. For defect correction coverage, remove the line from the billed amount.
  6. For government property coverage, check whether the policy excludes the losses described in the provision, and say so plainly in the cover note.
  7. Write one short note for each line: the category you chose, the clause that supports it, and the document you used to find the number.

Consider a hypothetical invoice with four insurance lines. The first is a policy the contract requires, so it needs its contract clause attached. The second is a general business policy, so it needs its own category and a sentence explaining why it sits where it does. The third is a self-insurance charge for the same kind of risk that purchased insurance would cover, so it needs the comparison before anyone can say how much is in excess. The fourth pays to correct the contractor's own defects, so it comes out of the billed amount under this provision. The invoice total is only right after all four decisions are made, not after the four lines are added together.

The order matters. If you total first and sort later, the total becomes the thing you defend, and the categories become an afterthought. Sorting first keeps each dollar tied to a reason, and that reason is what a reviewer will ask for.

Mistakes that cost owners the most

The first mistake is treating approval as allowability. Point 1 explains why this fails, and each cost still needs its own check.

The second mistake is billing self-insurance as one block. The rule removes the excess over comparable purchased insurance, and it names catastrophic-loss charges separately. A single self-insurance figure hides both questions. Split it, then test each part.

The third mistake is assuming that general business coverage inherits the treatment of required coverage. The provision lists the two separately, so they should be handled separately. Two policies that look alike on a broker's summary can sit in different places under the rule.

The fourth mistake is skipping the notes. When a reviewer asks where a number came from, a missing note turns a simple question into a search through old files. A one-line note on each line protects you when the invoice is questioned and makes your own review faster. For the job-level records behind those notes, see Job cost sheet: 3 cost lines to total on every job.

The fifth mistake is forcing a line into a category because the total has to match an expected figure. A line that does not fit should be questioned, not reshaped to fit the budget.

When a line is unclear, and which rulebook governs

If a line does not fit any category, stop and ask before billing. Ask the contracting officer or your cost advisor, and write the answer down with the date you received it. Do not guess and hope the reviewer will not look closely. A written question costs little, while a disallowed line can cost much more to unwind after it is paid.

Keep the approval record current as well. An approval describes a program as it was reviewed, so if the coverage, the carrier, or the self-insurance arrangement changes, the approval and your line-by-line sorting both need a fresh look before the next invoice goes out. Treat the approval as a dated fact in your file, not as a permanent answer to every future charge. For how to close out the file each job needs, see Job file closeout: 6 steps to track deadlines.

Which rulebook governs also matters. Not every funding source uses the FAR text, and the rules that apply to your award may come from a different place. The National Science Foundation's guide makes that explicit. It states: "In the case of any inconsistency between the coverage contained in the NSF Proposal and Award Policies and Procedures Guide and 2 CFR (including 2 CFR part 200), the coverage specified in 2 CFR applies." See the NSF allowability chapter for that guide's own text. If your work runs under an NSF award, that precedence rule decides which text controls when the two sources disagree. If your work runs under another agency or contract, identify its governing terms before you apply the FAR provision above. The text you are reading may not be the text that binds your award.

Approval gets the program through the door. Allowability is checked cost by cost. Sort each line into its category, measure self-insurance against purchased cover, and keep the record that shows how you arrived at each number.

Your next step

Before the next invoice goes out, pull every insurance line and write its category beside it, using the table above. Any line without a category stays off the bill until it has one.

Related guides: Asbestos pipe amount: the 260-foot federal line · Job-cost comparisons: 3 checks across periods · Extra repair work: 6 steps to get approval first.

Frequently asked questions

Does an approved insurance program make every premium allowable?

No. Approval is not a determination of allowability, so each premium still has to be sorted on its own.

Which insurance costs are named as unallowable?

Three kinds are named: insurance to protect against correcting the contractor's own defects, self-insurance charges for risks of catastrophic losses, and the excess over comparable purchased insurance, where purchased insurance is available.

What should I attach to a required insurance line?

Attach the contract clause or the approval record that makes the coverage required or approved, so the reason for the cost travels with the invoice line.

Sources

More field guides