Straight into the service manual page
WrenchQuarry
More

Repair estimate limits: 3 states and approval rules

WrenchQuarry Editorial Team · Published · 11 min read · How these guides are written

Michigan and Washington limit repair estimate overages; Florida requires written estimates above $150, including diagnosis, and sets storage timing.

Key takeaways

  • Itemize parts and labor before repair work begins.
  • Check Michigan's waiver condition and any customer request for contact.
  • Compare Washington charges before retail sales tax.
  • Record approval before extra work and date Florida storage notices.

Why the estimate is the line everyone watches

A repair estimate is the price a customer agrees to before work starts. This guide explains those rules for dispatchers, service advisors and team leads who write estimates, approve extra work or take the call when a bill comes in high.

Once the crew lifts the car, pulls a panel or opens the housing, the number starts to feel like a promise. When the final invoice lands well above it, the customer's first question is rarely about the parts. It is about whether anyone asked them.

That moment runs through the front of the shop. Dispatchers write or check the estimate, decide when a technician should stop and call in extra work, and answer the phone when a customer says the bill is higher than they were told. If the approval process is unclear, the shop ends up absorbing the cost, angering the customer or both.

Several states write limits on this gap into law. This post covers three of them. This post is not legal advice. Read the full section for your state before you change a form, a script or a pricing rule.

Michigan: an itemized estimate and a small overage allowance

Michigan starts with the estimate itself. Under the motor vehicle repair section of the Michigan Legislature site, a repair facility must give the customer a written estimate before it begins repair work, and that estimate must itemize the price for labor and parts "as closely as possible" (MCL 257.1332).

A single lump-sum line such as "brake job, lump sum" is a weak estimate under that wording. A stronger one lists the pads, rotors, hardware, fluid if it applies, and the labor time for each part of the job. The reader can see what the number is made of. Itemizing also makes the next step easier. When the crew finds something new, you can point to the exact line that changed. Use the estimate line item guide to review how those lines are recorded.

When no waiver is signed under subsection (3), the facility need not obtain oral or written consent for an excess charge within the smaller of 10% or $50.00, unless the customer specifically requests consent (MCL 257.1332).

The key word is lesser. The allowance is not 10 percent, and it is not $50. It is whichever of the two is smaller, so the figure depends on the size of the estimate:

  • On a smaller estimate, 10 percent is the lower figure, so that 10 percent amount is the allowance.
  • On a larger estimate, 10 percent is more than fifty dollars, so the allowance is fifty dollars.

Two cautions go with this rule. First, this summary does not cover the signed-waiver case under subsection (3). Second, the words "unless specifically requested by the customer" matter a great deal. If a customer has asked to be called about any increase, the allowance does not cover that request. The simplest dispatch habit is to call before going past the estimate, even when the allowance would cover the difference.

Illustrative example: checking the smaller allowance

An illustrative Michigan estimate is $50. With no signed waiver and no customer request for consent, compare 10% of $50, which is $5, with $50. The smaller amount is $5. That is the allowance for this example; it is not permission to ignore a customer's contact request.

Florida: a written estimate above $150 and a storage clock

Florida's rules begin with a dollar threshold. Chapter 559, section 905 of the 2024 Florida Statutes says that when a customer asks a shop to do repair work whose cost "will exceed $150 to the customer," the shop must prepare a written repair estimate. The estimate has to be in place "before effecting any diagnostic work or repair," and it must set out the estimated cost of the repair work, including diagnostic work (Florida Statutes 559.905).

That last part changes how shops should think about diagnosis. Teams often treat a diagnostic fee as a small step that happens before the "real" estimate. Under this wording, diagnostic work belongs inside the estimate. If the diagnosis is likely to push the job past $150, the estimate needs to say so before the technician starts looking.

The same section includes a customer acknowledgment written in capital letters:

> "I UNDERSTAND THAT, UNDER STATE LAW, I AM ENTITLED TO A WRITTEN ESTIMATE IF MY FINAL BILL WILL EXCEED $150."

Read the section to see how and when that statement is used. For your own forms, the sentence is a plain way to tell a customer why they are receiving a written estimate.

Florida also sets a rule about time. The text says that "storage charges may not accrue or be due and payable for a period of 3 working days from the date after such notification" (Florida Statutes 559.905). Keep a written record of exactly when the customer was notified, because the three-working-day period runs from the date after that notification.

For Florida, build the $150 written-estimate trigger, coverage of diagnosis, and storage timing into your process.

Washington: the ceiling and the pre-tax test

Washington's rule sets a ceiling tied to the written estimate. Under RCW 46.71.025, "the repair facility may not charge the customer more than one hundred ten percent, exclusive of retail sales tax, of the total shown on the written price estimate" (RCW 46.71.025).

If the estimate shows a total before sales tax, the ceiling applies to that pre-tax figure. Dispatchers who compare a tax-inclusive invoice with a pre-tax estimate will misjudge how close the job is to the line. Compare pre-tax with pre-tax, every time.

The same section sets out a customer-facing statement: "YOU ARE ENTITLED TO A WRITTEN PRICE ESTIMATE FOR THE REPAIRS YOU HAVE AUTHORIZED" (RCW 46.71.025). The word "authorized" matters. The customer is entitled to a written estimate for the repairs they approve, so approval and estimate belong together in your records.

The section also includes a warning sentence: "Contact me if the price will exceed this estimate by more than ten percent" (RCW 46.71.025). Whether or not your forms use that exact wording, the idea is sound. Tell the customer where the line is and what you will do when a job approaches it.

Then comes the exception. The section says: "Neither of these limitations apply if, before providing additional parts or labor the repair facility obtains either the oral or written authorization of the customer, or the customer's designee, to exceed the written price estimate" (RCW 46.71.025).

Two words carry the weight: before and providing. Authorization has to come before the additional parts or labor are provided. A call made after the new part is installed does not fit the exception, and neither does a note added to the invoice on the way out the door. Oral authorization is allowed under this wording, but an oral yes with no record is hard to prove. Write down who approved the change, when, what was approved and the new total.

What the three states have in common

The three rules differ in their numbers, but they share a pattern that helps any shop, including shops in states not covered here.

TopicMichiganFloridaWashington
Written estimate requiredBefore repair work beginsFor work over $150, before diagnosis or repairWritten price estimate for authorized repairs
Overage ruleAllowance without consent when no waiver is signed, unless the customer specifically requests consentWritten-estimate trigger and storage timingCeiling on the total, excluding retail sales tax
Key exception or timingSigned-waiver cases require separate reviewStorage charges may not accrue for 3 working days from the date after notificationCeiling does not apply if authorization comes before extra parts or labor

A workflow for dispatchers and team leads

The process below is general shop practice built around the rules above. Adjust it to your state, and check it against the full statute before you rely on it.

1. Write the estimate before any work, including diagnosis. In Florida, diagnostic work belongs in the estimate once the $150 threshold applies. In Michigan, the written estimate comes before repair work begins.

2. Itemize parts and labor. A line-item estimate makes every later change easier to explain.

3. Set a stop point for technicians. When a technician finds additional work, the job pauses at a defined point. The technician reports the finding to the dispatcher or team lead, who decides what happens next. This is shop practice, not a rule quoted from any statute, but it keeps the crew from making a pricing decision on the spot.

4. Get approval before the parts or labor go on. Call the customer, describe the finding in plain words, give the new total, and wait for an answer before the work continues.

5. Record the approval. Write down the customer's name, the time of the call, what was approved, the new total and who took the call. A text or email is better than a verbal yes, even where a verbal yes is allowed.

6. Know your state's line. Check the applicable limit and any customer contact request before the job continues.

7. Update the invoice to match the approvals. The final bill should match the approved estimate plus the approved changes. Any line that appears on the invoice but not in the approval record is a line you will have to defend. Review the repair job invoice checklist during that final comparison.

Writing an estimate that holds up

A strong estimate does four things. It shows the work, the parts, the labor and the total. It states the process for changes. It tells the customer what happens if the job runs over. And it is signed or acknowledged by the customer when your state or your shop requires that.

For the change process, a short sentence does the job: "If we find additional parts or labor, we will contact you before doing that work and give you the new total."

Keep the estimate in language the customer can read. Avoid internal shorthand such as "R&R," "EOP check" or "tech says." If a customer cannot tell what they are approving, they will question every change that follows. Also avoid vague lines like "misc. parts" or "shop supplies, as needed." Those lines invite disputes, because they give a reader no way to check the number. If a supply charge is part of your pricing, give it its own line and state how it is figured.

The approval record needs the same clarity. The table below shows an illustrative record in plain words.

RecordCustomer and contact methodDate and timeWork approvedRevised totalStaff member
ExampleCustomer contacted by phoneApproval recorded before extra workAdditional parts and labor describedRevised amount recorded before workPerson taking the call recorded

Common mistakes that cause overage disputes

Calling after the work is done. A call after installation is a notice, not a consent.

Treating a verbal "go ahead" as enough. A verbal approval with no record is weak evidence. Write it down the same day.

Leaving diagnosis off the estimate. A diagnosis billed as a separate afterthought can push a job over the threshold without anyone noticing.

Assuming the allowance is a right to bill up to it. The Michigan allowance is a rule about consent, not a promise to the customer.

Mixing tax into the comparison. If the team compares a tax-inclusive invoice with a pre-tax estimate, the numbers will be wrong, and the wrong number will drive the wrong call.

Forgetting the clock. If the notice is not recorded, the shop cannot show when the period began.

A short checklist for each job

  • Written estimate in place before work begins, with diagnosis included.
  • Parts and labor itemized, not lumped together.
  • Customer contact method and approval rules written on the estimate.
  • Stop point set for technicians who find extra work.
  • Approval recorded before any extra parts or labor are provided.
  • Pre-tax total checked against the estimate for Washington jobs.
  • Michigan increases checked against the allowance, and any customer request to be contacted honored.
  • Florida jobs over $150 confirmed to have a written estimate, and storage notices dated.
  • Final invoice matches the estimate plus the approved changes.

Check an estimate today

Take an estimate and its final invoice today. Compare each changed line with its approval record, and check that approval came before the extra work.

Related guides: Repair estimate update in 72 hours: 5 steps to follow · Home estimate 3-day cancel notice before signing.

Questions about repair estimates

Does Florida have the same percentage cap?

Florida's written-estimate trigger, diagnosis requirement and storage timing are separate from Michigan's and Washington's overage limits. Check the full Florida section before setting a billing rule.

What should the approval record include?

Record the customer's name, contact method, date and time, approved work, revised total and staff member handling the approval.

Sources

More field guides