Straight into the service manual page
WrenchQuarry
More

Van stock surprise count: 5 checks for accuracy

WrenchQuarry Editorial Team · Published · 11 min read · How these guides are written

Why a surprise count finds what a scheduled one misses

For a surprise van stock count, count each line, compare quantities, mark progress, trace unrecorded movements, and sort differences by cause.

A scheduled count gives people time to get ready. A van that was short last week can look complete on the afternoon you planned to check it, because someone restocked it that morning or moved parts over from another van. An unannounced count shows the van as it is when you arrive, and that is the whole point of the exercise. You are not trying to catch anyone out. You are trying to see the real state of the stock before anyone has had a chance to tidy it.

Accounting uses the same idea. The OpenStax principles of accounting textbook describes auditors performing "procedures at locations on a surprise or unannounced basis, for example, observing inventory on unexpected dates or at unexpected locations or counting cash on a surprise basis." It also notes that such testing "is used to catch accounting fraud."

Your van check is not an audit, and you should not treat every difference as fraud. The same textbook says auditors are hired to "obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements are free of material misstatement, whether caused by error or fraud." The useful part for a van is the last few words. A short line can come from an honest mistake or from something worse, and your job is to find out which before you decide what it means.

Van stock also matters for a practical reason. A technician who reaches a job without the part it needs either makes a second trip or delays the repair. An over-stocked van ties up parts that could be sitting on a shelf where they are needed. A spot-check tells you which of those problems you actually have, rather than the one you suspect.

Tell your technicians that spot-checks happen and can come at any time. Do not announce dates. The surprise is in the timing, not in the purpose, and a team that knows the checks are routine has less reason to feel singled out when one arrives.

Before you go: decide who counts and who writes

A surprise count goes better with two people. One person opens bins, reads each quantity aloud, and handles the parts. The other writes every number on the sheet and does not look at the expected figure while the count is running. Keep those roles fixed for the whole visit. If the person writing also does the counting, the numbers tend to drift toward what that person expects to see, and the sheet stops being a record of what was actually there.

Agree in advance who signs off the sheet and who the technician should call if a question comes up. The sign-off person should have the authority to ask about any line and to hold the sheet until the question is answered. A count with no named owner tends to leave differences unresolved, because everyone assumes someone else will follow up.

Pick the time of the visit with the job schedule in mind. If a technician is in the middle of a repair, ask them to finish that job or step back to a safe point before you start. Counting while parts are being unpacked or moved gives you numbers that do not hold still, and you will not be able to tell a short line from a part that is simply in transit.

Build the expected list before you arrive

Before you go to any van, you need a list of what it should hold. Export the van's stock from your system. If you do not have an export, use the last count sheet that someone signed off. Keep a separate sheet for each van, so that a difference in one van cannot disappear into a combined list covering several.

Each line should be clear enough that someone standing at the van can find the item without asking. Use the exact name and code the system shows, and put the bin or location beside them. Parts with close names are easy to mix up on a shelf, so the code matters more than the name when two items look alike. If the same part appears under two codes in your system, note that on the sheet so the count does not treat it as two separate stocks by accident.

The sheet does most of the work, so set it up with care. These columns cover what you need:

ColumnWhat to writeWhy it matters
Item name and codeThe name and code exactly as the system shows themStops similar parts being counted as one
Bin or locationWhere the item is kept in the vanLets you find it fast and spot parts kept in the wrong place
Expected quantityWhat the system says the van should hold; cover until the count is writtenThe number you compare against later
Counted quantityThe quantity counted while the expected column is coveredKeeps the expected number out of the count
DifferenceCounted minus expected, worked out after the countMakes short and over lines easy to see
NoteAnything unusual, including items not on the listKeeps the context for the fifth check

If the expected number is in front of the person counting, it is easy to stop as soon as they reach it. Cover the expected quantity column until the counted quantity is written.

Look at the last sheet for each van before you go. If the same items were short last time, mark them on the new sheet as lines to look at closely. That is not a judgement about the technician. It is a reminder of where the records have been weakest.

First check: count every line in the same order

Walk each van the same way every time. Start at the same door, work from the top shelf down to the floor, and finish at the back. A fixed route means you do not skip a drawer on one visit and catch it on the next, and it makes differences between visits easier to read. If the van has locked cabinets, have the technician open them at the start, so you are not chasing keys while the count is running.

Count every line on the sheet, including the lines you expect to be fine. Count what is there, not what should be there. Write the counted number before you look at the expected one, and only then work out the difference. This order matters more than it seems, because a number you have already seen tends to become the number you write down.

Count items that are not on the sheet, too. If you find a part the system does not list for this van, write it in the note column with a short description and the bin where it was. Do not correct the sheet on the spot. Flagging is enough at this stage, because the fix comes later, after you know the cause.

Ask the technician not to add or remove parts during the count. Parts that move mid-count make every number on the sheet suspect, and you will not be able to tell whether a line is short or the part has simply been moved to another drawer. If the technician needs something from the van, let them take it once you have finished that section, and note the time in the note column.

Take a photo of each bin before you open it, if your policy allows photographs on site. A photo is a record you can compare later, and it can help resolve a disagreement about where a part was standing when you arrived. Check your own rules about phones and images before you start.

Second check: compare each count with the system

Subtract the expected number from the counted number. A negative difference means the van holds fewer than the system says. A positive difference means it holds more. Write the difference on the sheet, but leave the system alone for now. The first job is to record what you found, not to change the records to match the count. Changing records during the visit makes it hard to see later what the original state was.

Then look at the values the system shows for those lines, not only the quantities. The stock entry page in the Frappe documentation includes the question "Why is my valuation rate or stock value negative or abnormally high?" The question is a useful reminder that a number can be wrong in the system even when the shelf is right. A line with an odd value is worth tracing back to the entries that created it, because a bad entry can make a line look short or over. If your system is not built on that software, look for the same kind of check in whatever report you use.

Then compare counts across vans. If the same item is short in one van and over in another, it may have been moved without a record. A pattern across several vans often tells you more than any single line, so keep the sheets together and read them side by side.

Third check: mark each line as you go

Put a mark on each line the moment you count it. A printed sheet and a pen will do. So will a tablet or a phone. The point is that the mark sits next to the line, so the record of what you reached lives on the page and not in your memory.

The Sortly help page on creating labels describes a similar habit in its bulk editing tools: "Click the checkmark on each item, or choose All from the Bulk Edit Bar." That page is about printing labels, not counting stock, but the lesson carries over. A checkmark should mean that you actually reached that item.

Be careful with select-all options. Use them only after the count is finished, not before. If you mark everything at the start, a line skipped at the back of the van will look counted, and the sheet will no longer tell you what was checked.

If the count is interrupted, note where you stopped. Mark the last counted line, write the time in the note column, and restart from the next line when you can. This keeps the record honest, and it stops anyone from assuming the rest of the van was checked when it was not.

Before you leave, go back over the sheet and look for blank counted cells. Every blank should either be counted now or explained in the note column. A sheet with gaps is not finished, even if the difference column looks tidy.

Fourth check: look for stock that moved without a record

Many differences come from movement that was never written down. A part is used on a job and not logged. A returned part goes into the wrong bin. A transfer between vans happens before anyone updates the system. None of these is theft, and all of them show up as a difference on the sheet. Your job at this stage is to find out which one you are looking at.

Before you decide anything, ask the technician what they used since the last count. Ask open questions such as "What did you use since last time?" rather than "Did you take anything?" An open question gets a fuller answer, and it does not put the technician on the defensive. Then compare the answer with the job records and any return slips you have. Write down what matched and what did not.

Look around the van and the nearby bins. A part may have been put in the next drawer over, or placed in a bin meant for a different van. That can explain a short line in one place and an over line somewhere else. Check the neighbouring bins before you mark a line as missing.

Also check returns that have not yet been checked in. Parts that came back from a job and are sitting in a box for the office are easy to lose track of, and one question to the person who handles returns can often settle them. Ask that person to show you the box, rather than relying on a verbal answer.

Fifth check: sort each difference by cause before you decide

Not every difference means the same thing, so do not treat them alike. Use this table to choose where to look first:

Difference you seeLikely cause to test firstWhat to check
Short line, nothing in the noteUse that was never loggedJob records and the technician's account
Over lineReturn or transfer with no recordReturn slips, transfers, and the other vans
Part in the wrong binRestocking habit or a moved partBin labels and the location column
Odd value or quantity in the systemData entry or a faulty stock entryThe stock entries behind that line
Short line nothing explainsLoss or theft, possiblyEscalation under your own policy

Read the table as a starting point, not a verdict. A cause is a hypothesis until you check the records behind it. Write the cause you tested in the note column, along with what you found, so the next person can see how you reasoned.

Then decide what happens next, following your own policy. An over line may only need to be checked in. A short line that no record explains should go to the sign-off person named before the visit, who decides whether it needs a deeper review.

A single count rarely settles whether a difference comes from error or fraud. Do not accuse anyone on the strength of one count. Ask for the records, check them, and then decide.

After the visit, tell the technician what happened and what you will do next. Keep it short and specific. If the difference turned out to be a logging gap, say so and show them the entry that should have been made. A technician who sees how the sheet is used is more likely to help keep it accurate next time, and the sheets you keep from each visit are what will show you whether a pattern is forming.

Sources

More field guides