Straight into the service manual page
WrenchQuarry
More

3 vendor testimonial figures to check before buying

WrenchQuarry Editorial Team · Published · 13 min read · How these guides are written

The three figures to check in a vendor testimonial are a growth percentage, a count of star reviews, and a date of switch. None of them is a promise to you, but each one raises a specific question you can ask before you sign.

  • The growth percentage: ask what metric it measures, over what period, and against what baseline
  • The star-review count: separate the customer's own review intake from the software's app rating
  • The switch date: use it to judge how current the quote is and what the migration involved
  • Write down your own three figures first: the growth you need, the review workflow you want, and your live-by date
  • Ask the same questions of every vendor so the answers stay comparable

What a testimonial actually tells you

A testimonial gives you one customer's story on the day the vendor collected it. That story may be honest and still leave your decision open. The three figures worth pausing on are a growth percentage, a count of star reviews, and a date of switch. Those are the numbers that catch your eye when you are comparing field-service software side by side. You can check each of them against what your own operation needs.

Workiz's pricing and plans page, which carries customer quotes alongside its plan tiers, offers three examples worth pausing on. One customer wrote, "With Workiz, our growth skyrocketed over 300% — everything's faster and easier now." Another wrote, "We are getting so many 5-star reviews and more business!" A third noted a switch from ServiceTitan in summer 2023. Those are the three figures: the 300% growth claim, the star-review count, and the switch date. None of them is a promise to you. Each one raises a specific question you can ask before you sign.

This page walks you through those three checks. It also covers what a testimonial cannot show at all, and how to write down what you actually need so a good quote does not decide your purchase for you.

How we evaluated this topic

We looked at how three figures in field-service software testimonials can and cannot inform a buying decision. We used published customer quotes from vendor pages, specifically Workiz's pricing page, as our working examples. We did not audit any customer's revenue, review profile, or switch history. We did not run a survey of field-service businesses. Nothing here ranks software or claims one product performs better than another.

Our method is to take each figure a testimonial offers and ask what a careful buyer can verify from it, what remains unknown, and what question to put to the vendor. Where a source speaks to a general principle about how quoted examples or trial periods are described, we use that to sharpen your questions. We do not extend any source's statement beyond the situation it describes.

Figure one: the growth percentage

The growth percentage is the loudest figure in a testimonial, and it is the one you should trust the least without more context. Workiz's page carries the claim that a customer's growth "skyrocketed over 300%." That is a real sentence a customer agreed to publish. It is not a benchmark, a projection, or a rate you should expect.

Ask the vendor what the percentage measures. Growth in revenue, jobs completed, customers served, and crew hours are four different things. A business that doubled its marketing spend could grow revenue without changing its margin. A business that added a second location could grow jobs without improving either. The percentage alone does not tell you which one moved.

Ask over what period. A 300% rise over two years and a 300% rise over two quarters imply very different stories. Testimonials rarely state the window. Without it, you cannot compare the figure to your own timeline.

Ask against what baseline. Growth from a small starting base is easier to reach than growth from an established one. If the customer was a two-truck operation, a tripling looks different than the same percentage from a twenty-truck firm.

Ask what the software contributed. Workiz's page also carries the line, "Profit more from your existing team and grow more efficiently." That is a general benefit claim, not a measurement. It suggests the kind of outcome a customer might attribute to a tool. It does not tell you which levers produced the 300% in the other quote.

Now test the figure against your own numbers. Pull twelve months of your own job counts, revenue, and average ticket. Decide what growth you would need for the purchase to be worth it. That figure comes from your books, not from a testimonial. If the vendor's customer achieved 300% growth in a line of business you do not run, the number has no bearing on your decision.

Ask the vendor whether the customer who gave the quote is willing to speak with you. A short call answers the four questions above faster than any page can. If the vendor will not connect you, treat the percentage as marketing copy. It may still be true. You simply cannot verify it.

Figure two: the star-review count

The second figure is the count of five-star reviews. Workiz's page quotes a customer saying, "We are getting so many 5-star reviews and more business!" That is a customer describing their own experience with review generation. It is not a count of the software's reviews, and it is not a measure of the software's performance.

Separate two things that get mixed up in your head when you read that line. The customer is talking about reviews their own business received, presumably from their own customers, after using the software. The number of reviews on an app store or a third-party site is a different figure entirely. Neither figure tells you the other.

For the customer's own review count, ask what drove it. A tool that sends a review request after a job can increase the volume of reviews a business collects. The volume does not tell you the quality of the experience, only that more customers were asked. Ask the vendor what the request workflow looks like, when it fires, and whether a customer can decline without friction.

For the software's own review profile, go to the review sites yourself and look. Read the one-star and two-star reviews first. They tell you what breaks, how support responds, and whether a complaint was resolved. Then read the recent five-star reviews to see what customers praise now rather than two years ago. That reading is yours to do; no testimonial can replace it.

Ask what a five-star review means in the workflow. If the software requests reviews only after a job marked complete, the count reflects completed jobs, not all jobs. Jobs that were cancelled, disputed, or never closed would not appear. That is a normal design choice, and it shapes what the number shows.

Compare the review practice to your own. If you already collect reviews by text or email, a tool that duplicates that process adds a subscription cost without adding a result. If you collect none today, the workflow may be the actual gain. Workiz's page sells plans for field-service teams; the quote about reviews belongs to a customer who used them. Your decision turns on whether that workflow is missing in your shop.

Figure three: the switch date

The third figure is a date. Workiz's page includes the line, "I switched to Workiz from Service Titan in summer 2023 and have loved it ever since." The date tells you when the customer started on the product. It tells you nothing else on its own.

Use the date to judge how current the quote is. A customer who switched in summer 2023 was still on the product when the vendor published the quote. That means the relationship lasted at least from that switch until publication. It does not tell you whether they are still on it today, because the quote as supplied gives no publication date, so its currency cannot be confirmed.

Use the date to judge what the customer could compare. Someone who switched has direct experience of both products in their own operation. That makes their view of the migration more useful than a view from a customer who never left. Ask what the migration involved: data moved, jobs re-entered, training given, and how long the old system stayed open in parallel.

Use the date to judge what has changed since. Field-service software ships updates. A customer's experience in the months after a 2023 switch may not reflect the product you would buy now. Ask the vendor what changed in the product since that customer's switch, and whether the customer still uses the features they praised.

Here is how the three figures compare when you line them up:

Figure in the quoteWhat it measuresWhat you ask the vendor
Over 300% growthOne customer's unspecified growth metricWhich metric, over what period, from what baseline
So many 5-star reviewsThe customer's own review intake, not the app's ratingWhat triggers a review request, and what jobs are excluded
Summer 2023 switchWhen the customer left a named competitorWhat the migration cost in time and data

What a testimonial cannot show you

A testimonial cannot show you your own numbers. It describes one business, in one market, at one point in time, chosen by the vendor for publication. That selection process is not a criticism of the customer's honesty. It is a limit on what the quote can carry.

Testimonials do not show you the cost of switching. The quote about switching in summer 2023 does not mention what the customer paid to move, how long the old system stayed live, or whether any job history was lost. Those costs sit outside the quote. Ask the vendor for them in writing before you sign.

Testimonials do not show you the cost of staying. Plan prices, add-on modules, seat fees, and usage limits live on the pricing page and in the order form. Workiz's page presents its plans alongside the customer quotes. Read the plan terms with the same care you give the quotes. A glowing customer story attached to a plan that lacks a feature you need does not help you.

Testimonials do not show you how support behaves on a bad day. The quote does not show how the customer's support experience went on a difficult day. The quote captures a summary feeling. Ask what happens when a dispatcher calls at 7pm with a no-show. Ask for the support hours, the response target, and whether an escalation path exists.

Testimonials do not show you the tool's limits under load. A quote from a business that runs a handful of crews says nothing about a business running many. Ask the vendor whether any published customer operates at your scale, and ask to speak to one.

One more limit worth naming: a testimonial is written for the vendor's page. The customer approved the words, and the vendor chose where to place them. Both parties wanted the quote to read well. That is normal and it does not make the quote false. It does mean the quote answers the vendor's marketing question, not your buying question.

How quoted examples can mislead

Vendors often illustrate a feature with an example. An example shows a shape; it does not guarantee your data fits it. Atlassian's documentation on automation service limits describes a scenario where "The following examples results in 3,500 items or more, depending on the number of branches." The sentence is about branches multiplying item counts in an automation run. Read it as a warning that complexity compounds.

Apply the same habit to a testimonial's example. When a customer describes a workflow that saved them time, ask how many steps that workflow has. Ask what happens when a job has exceptions, split payments, or multiple crew members. A smooth example from a simple job does not describe your busiest Tuesday.

The same applies to trial periods and date logic. Stripe's documentation on trial offers explains that a two-month trial starting on February 28 ends on April 28, regardless of whether the billing cycle anchor falls on the 29th or 30th of the month. The rule is narrow and specific to Stripe's trial configuration. Its broader lesson is that a stated duration can behave differently than you expect once a calendar edge appears.

Carry that lesson to any trial or pilot the field-service vendor offers. Ask when the trial starts, when it ends, what happens at the boundary, and what you are charged if you go past it. A testimonial that says a customer "loved it ever since" a summer 2023 switch does not tell you what happened at the end of their trial.

Turning the three checks into a short list

Write down your own three figures before you read another testimonial. First, the growth you need the software to support. Pull it from your own job counts and revenue over a period you choose. Second, the review outcome you want, stated as a workflow rather than a number: who gets asked, when, and on what jobs. Third, the date by which you need the new system live, counting back from your busiest season.

Now read the testimonials again with your three figures in hand. A quote about 300% growth matters only if your own growth target is in that league and the customer's business resembles yours. A quote about star reviews matters only if your shop is missing the request workflow. A quote about a summer 2023 switch matters only if the migration story answers your own timeline question.

Rank your short list by how many of your three figures each vendor can address with specifics. Specifics means a named customer willing to speak, a written migration plan, and a clear plan term. A page full of quotes with none of those three is a page you have already read as far as it goes.

Then ask the same questions of every vendor on the list. Same questions keep the answers comparable. If one vendor answers the growth question with a metric and a period, and another answers with a slogan, you have your comparison without needing a scorecard.

Questions to ask before you sign

Put these to the vendor in writing and keep the replies with your order form.

  • What does the growth percentage in that customer quote measure, over what period, and from what baseline?
  • Which customers on your page would speak to me, and what is the publication date of their quote?
  • What does the review request workflow trigger on, and which jobs never receive a request?
  • What did the switching customer pay in time and data to migrate, and how long did the old system stay open?
  • What has changed in the product since that customer's switch date?
  • What are the support hours, the response target, and the escalation path after hours?
  • Does any published customer operate at my crew count and job volume?
  • What are the plan inclusions, the add-on costs, and the seat fees on the plan I would actually buy?
  • When does a trial start and end, what happens at the boundary, and what am I charged if I pass it?
  • What do I own at the end: my job history, my customer records, and my export format?

Those ten questions cover the gaps the three figures leave open. They also put the vendor's claims next to your own numbers, which is where a buying decision belongs.

FAQ

Does a 300% growth quote mean I will grow 300%? No. The quote describes one customer's result on an unstated metric over an unstated period. Your own growth depends on your market, your crews, your pricing, and your sales effort. Use the figure only to decide whether the vendor's typical customer resembles you.

Should I weight a five-star app rating over a customer's own review quote? They answer different questions. A customer's own review quote describes the review workflow inside their business. An app rating describes other buyers' experience of the software. Read both, and read the low ratings on the app listing for the failures and the support responses.

What if the vendor will not let me speak to the quoted customer? Treat the quote as copy. It may be accurate and it remains unverified. Ask for any other customer at your scale, and if none exists, weigh that absence heavily against the vendor.

Is a switch-date quote worthless if I am not leaving that same competitor? Ask what the move cost them in time and data. That answer helps even when your current system has a different name.

Do trial terms matter if a testimonial says the customer loved the product? Yes. The trial determines what you pay at the boundary and what you can export if you leave. Ask when it starts, when it ends, and what happens if you pass the end date. Keep the answer with your order.

What should I do first before reading any more testimonials? Write your own three figures: the growth you need, the review workflow you want, and your live-by date. Everything after that is comparison, not persuasion.

Sources

More field guides