L&I allows a deduction for covering a cash shortage in the till, with three conditions. The page says the deduction applies "if the business has established policies regarding cash acceptance, the employee has sole access to the till, and the employee counted the cash at the start and end of the shift." Paycheck deductions
Read that as three tests. All three need to be met.
Policy first. To document the cash policy, write down how cash is taken, recorded, and handed over at a counter, a parts window, or a job site. A habit that everyone follows but nobody wrote down is hard to prove. Write the policy, date it, and have each tech acknowledge it.
Sole access. Check who can open the till before assigning responsibility for a shortage. A shared drawer, a spare key held by a dispatcher, or a second tech who takes over mid-shift prevents you from showing sole access. If anyone else can open the till, you cannot show that the shortage belongs to one person.
Counted at start and end. A close-out count alone does not meet the test. Use a signed start sheet and a signed end sheet, and keep both with the daily sales record.
Here is how that works. Say a tech runs a counter alone, signs a start count, and signs an end count. The drawer is short compared with the sales record. Each condition is documented, so the deduction has a basis. Now change one fact: a dispatcher also holds a key. The shortage may be real, but you can no longer show sole access.
A variance on a count is not the same thing as proof of a shortage. Change making, a customer paid with the wrong bill, a sale rung up twice, or a payment record that was never entered can all produce a gap between the drawer and the record. Before you call something a shortage, compare the start count, the end count, the sales record, and the deposit. Only the gap that remains after those checks is the amount you would be looking at under this condition.
Common mistakes to avoid:
- Assuming a close-out count is enough without a start count.
- Letting several people use one drawer and then charging only one of them.
- Keeping the cash policy in a binder that nobody has signed.