Straight into the service manual page
WrenchQuarry
More

2 kinds of change between 1981-2010 and 1991-2020 normals

WrenchQuarry Editorial Team · Published · 12 min read · How these guides are written

Two kinds of change explain why 1991-2020 climate normals differ from 1981-2010: climatic shifts in actual weather patterns, and non-climatic changes in the underlying data itself. Only the climatic half should influence how you adjust crew plans.

  • The climatic half reflects real weather shifts: a zonal pattern made the western two-thirds of the northern U.S. wetter and cooler, with temperatures dropping by more than 2°F in parts of the Dakotas and January precipitation rising 10–25% on the edges of the cooler north-central zone, while the West, the lee of the Rockies, and Texas warmed by up to 2°.
  • The non-climatic half comes from NCEI rerunning homogenization in 2021 (rather than 2011) and from additions and corrections made to the historical record between the 2011 and early 2021 data holdings.
  • Separate the two forces before touching a schedule: a real climatic shift changes your crew plan, while a data-driven shift changes nothing about how you staff.
  • Use three checks to tell them apart—map pattern, magnitude, and source version—then anchor planning on regional patterns rather than individual station numbers.

What changed when the normals rolled over

You set crew plans from a set of monthly averages called climate normals. For years your benchmarks came from the 1981-2010 period. Then a newer baseline replaced it. Many long-time users of NCEI's station-based normals wonder how the 1991-2020 values that were released in 2021 differ from the 1981-2010 values released in 2011, as the National Centers for Environmental Information (NCEI) U.S. Climate Normals page explains. The answer matters to you directly, because the shift you see between those two baselines is not one single thing.

In fact there are two kinds of change at work. The first is climatic: the weather genuinely shifted between the two windows. The second is non-climatic: the underlying data itself changed. Partly, NCEI rebuilt and corrected its historical records before publishing the new set. If you do not separate the two, you can mistake a data cleanup for a real weather change—or the other way around.

This post walks through both kinds of change, shows what they mean for seasonal crew planning, and gives you a practical way to read the numbers before you lock in schedules.

How the two normal periods differ

The 1981-2010 and 1991-2020 station normals use data that was homogenized at different times (2011 for the first time period, and 2021 for the second), NCEI states on its normals page. Homogenization is the process that removes non-climatic artifacts from a station record. A station may move a few hundred feet. An instrument may be swapped for a newer model. A nearby building may start shading a rain gauge. Homogenization aligns the whole time series with current station site and instrument characteristics so that it can be compared to today's measurements. It also, as NCEI notes, creates substantial differences between the 2021 and 2011 normals calculations.

So when you open two sets of normals and see a value that moved, you are seeing the sum of two separate forces. One force is the climate itself behaving differently across the two windows. The other is the processing pipeline behaving differently because NCEI did more work on the data before publishing.

There is a second, quieter source of non-climatic difference. The non-climatic differences arise primarily from the fact that the 1981-2010 normals were calculated from the 2011 version of NCEI's data holdings, while the 1991-2020 normals are based on a version from early 2021 which incorporates additions and corrections made to the historical record over the previous decade. Additions include stations that were not in the earlier holdings. Corrections include fixes made when errors were found later. Both kinds of change push values around without any real weather at all.

Here is a compact side-by-side of the two baselines and how each was produced.

Aspect1981-2010 normals1991-2020 normals
Released20112021
Data version used2011 holdingsEarly 2021 holdings
Homogenization pass20112021

Those three rows summarize the non-climatic side. The climatic side is the next section.

The climatic half: real shifts in the numbers

When NCEI compares the two normal sets on the map, it describes patterns that clearly reflect weather behavior. A strong zonal pattern in the western two-thirds of the northern U.S. marked both wetter and cooler normals for 1991–2020 than 1981–2010. Zonal means the flow runs mostly west to east rather than looping north and south. Under that pattern, the northern band picked up more precipitation and dropped in temperature.

Regional detail follows from that. The entire northern tier is cooler, but changes reach more than -2°F in parts of the Dakotas. If you staff winter work out of the Dakotas, a shift of that size can change how long a crew can work outdoors before cold policy kicks in. It can change how you stage heaters, hot drinks, and rotation breaks.

Precipitation moved too. On the western and eastern edges of the cooler north-central zone, precipitation increased by 10–25% in January. For a dispatcher planning January, 10–25% more snow or rain in a zone you already cover changes plow hours, salt orders, and how many crews you hold on call.

The pattern is not uniform, though. However, the entire West and lee of the Rocky Mountains and Texas are all considerably (up to 2°) warmer. That warmth matters for shoulder-season work. Warmer normals can shift the start of the paving or line-stripe window earlier in the year. It can also cut how many cold-weather days you plan for, freeing crews for other work.

Notice that these are all climatic statements. They describe the weather across the two windows. A dispatcher reading them should treat them as real changes in the baseline, not as processing noise.

Why the non-climatic half trips people up

The non-climatic half is quieter and more confusing. Nothing about the weather changed, yet the printed number moved. NCEI is explicit on its normals page about what happens in the homogenization step. The process aligns the whole time series with current station site and instrument characteristics so that it can be compared to today's measurements, but it also creates substantial differences between the 2021 and 2011 normals calculations.

Read that carefully. Homogenization exists to make an old record comparable to today. That is a good goal. But the side effect is that rerunning it a decade later produces a different output than the earlier run. Your July average did not change in the sky. It changed on the page.

The additions and corrections to NCEI's holdings between 2011 and early 2021 push values the same way. A station that arrived in the holdings later can alter the regional average around it. A corrected typo in an old monthly total can nudge a season. None of it is weather.

Here is the practical implication for you. If you compare old internal benchmarks to a new normal and the new number looks off, do not assume your climate changed overnight. Ask whether the difference is climatic or non-climatic first. The two call for opposite responses. A real climatic shift changes your crew plan. A data-driven shift changes nothing about how you staff.

A quick way to tell them apart

Use three checks before you touch a schedule.

Map pattern check. Does the change follow a broad regional pattern NCEI describes? A coherent zone that is cooler and wetter, or warmer, is almost always climatic. An isolated station that looks different from every neighbor is more likely a data artifact.

Magnitude check. Changes that reach more than 2°F in parts of the Dakotas, or up to 2° warmer in the West and lee of the Rockies and Texas, are the magnitudes reported in NCEI's comparison of the two normals. Treat similar magnitudes as climatic until proven otherwise.

Source version check. If the number came from the 2011 version of holdings and you are comparing it to one from early 2021, the gap includes a known non-climatic component. Flag it as mixed before you plan around it.

If you cannot decide which force moved a value, ask your regional NCEI contact or a local climatologist. One plain question—"is this difference climatic or processing-driven?"—is enough to settle it.

What this means for seasonal crew planning

Your job is to translate a normal into a schedule. That means deciding how many crews to hire for the season, which weeks to hold peak staffing, and where to place crews so travel time stays short. Both kinds of change feed that decision.

Start with the climatic half. Wetter and cooler normals across the western two-thirds of the northern U.S. suggest more hours of precipitation-driven work in that band. The January precipitation increase of 10–25% on the edges of the cooler north-central zone tells you where winter work pressure grew. The cooling of 2°F or more in parts of the Dakotas tells you where cold-weather constraints tightened. On the flip side, warmth of up to 2° across the West, the lee of the Rockies, and Texas suggests a longer warm-season window in those areas.

Now layer in the non-climatic half. When you read a value, remember that part of its distance from your old benchmark comes from a data rebuild. Do not staff to that part. Staff to the climatic part. In practice this means you should look for patterns across your whole service area rather than reacting to a single station's new number.

A useful habit: keep two columns in your planning sheet. One column holds the value as published in the newer normals. The other holds your working value after you decide how much of the gap is climatic. The first column is your reference. The second column drives the schedule. This keeps the data rebuild from quietly inflating or deflating your crew count.

Worked example: a northern-tier depot

Imagine you run a depot on the northern tier, near the zone NCEI describes as cooler. Your old winter plan was built on 1981-2010 normals. You pull the 1991-2020 set and see the winter temperature column lower. The regional pattern supports that.

You also see a January precipitation column that sits above your old one. The 10–25% increase NCEI describes for the edges of the cooler north-central zone lines up with where your depot sits. That points to more January hours of weather-driven work.

So you adjust in two directions at once. You add a little buffer to January staffing because the climatic signal is wetter. You keep your cold-rotation rules where they are as a planning choice, since the regional cooling is real. Then you look at your individual stations. Where a station moved far more than the regional pattern would suggest, you do not chase it. You note it as possibly non-climatic and leave the crew plan alone.

That last step is the discipline. The regional pattern is trustworthy for planning. A single outlier station often is not.

How to read your normals without overreacting

Reading the numbers well is most of the work. A few habits keep you from swinging your plan every time a new set lands.

Anchor on the pattern, not the point. NCEI's comparison describes whole zones: the northern tier cooler, the western two-thirds of the northern U.S. in a zonal wetter-and-cooler pattern, the West and lee of the Rockies and Texas warmer. Plan from zones.

Know your baseline's vintage. Your 1981-2010 values came from 2011 holdings and a 2011 homogenization. Your 1991-2020 values came from early 2021 holdings and a 2021 homogenization. Any gap between them carries both kinds of change.

Treat additions and corrections as noise for planning. NCEI incorporated additions and corrections to the historical record over the decade before publishing the newer set. Those moves do not reflect weather in your service area.

Revisit, do not rebuild, each season. A normals set is a long-run baseline, not a season forecast. You update your crew plan each year from operational demand, and you use the normals to sanity-check that demand.

Keep your old sheet for one more cycle. Running both the old and new normals side by side for one planning round shows you how much your plan actually moves. If it barely moves, the non-climatic changes were mostly cosmetic for your area.

The goal is stable schedules that still respect real shifts. Big swings in your crew plan should come from observed demand and clear regional patterns, not from the quiet churn in a data pipeline.

Checklist before you lock the season plan

Work through this once, in order, before you publish schedules.

Confirm your baseline. Write down which normals set each figure came from and when that set was released.

Separate the two forces. For every figure you plan around, mark it climatic, non-climatic, or mixed.

Check the regional pattern. Does the change match a pattern NCEI describes for your zone?

Look for outliers. A single station far from its neighbors deserves a second look, not a schedule change.

Decide your working values. Fill the working column of your sheet with the values you will actually staff to, ensuring each entry reflects the final staffing plan.

Map crews to zones. Place crews where the climatic patterns say pressure grew, and hold cold-weather crews lighter where warmth shortened the cold-weather season.

Set your review date. Put a reminder to revisit the sheet after the first major weather event of the season.

Write down open questions. Anything the sources leave unclear goes on a short list to ask a local climatologist or your NCEI contact.

If you finish the checklist and your plan looks roughly like last year's, that is a legitimate result. The climatic changes NCEI describes are regional. They nudge a plan. They rarely overturn one.

FAQ

Do I have to switch to the 1991-2020 normals?
Nothing forces you to change your internal benchmark overnight. What matters is that you know which set each figure came from. If your plan documents say 1981-2010, label them that way. When you pull newer figures, label those too. Mixing unlabeled sets is what causes confusion, not the switch itself.

If a number moved, is my climate definitely different?
Not necessarily. Both kinds of change are in play. The homogenization rerun and the additions and corrections to holdings both move values without weather changing. Look for a matching regional pattern before you call a difference climatic.

Why did NCEI change the data at all?
The homogenization step exists so an old record can be compared fairly to today's measurements. As NCEI puts it, the process aligns the whole time series with current station site and instrument characteristics. The side effect is that rerunning it a decade later yields a different result than the earlier run.

Which set should a brand-new depot use?
Start from the current published set and label it clearly. You have no legacy internal benchmarks to defend. Your first planning round should record the release year alongside every figure so future comparisons stay clean.

Does the warmer pattern in the West and Texas mean I can cut winter crews there?
The warmth NCEI describes reaches up to 2° across the West, the lee of the Rocky Mountains, and Texas. That suggests a longer warm-season window. It does not by itself tell you how many winter hours you can release, since your local demand still drives the actual count. Use the normal as a check, not the sole input.

Who do I ask when I am stuck?
Take one specific figure and one specific question to a local climatologist or your NCEI contact. Ask whether the difference you see is climatic or processing-driven. One answer usually settles the whole comparison.

Sources

More field guides