The non-climatic half is quieter and more confusing. Nothing about the weather changed, yet the printed number moved. NCEI is explicit on its normals page about what happens in the homogenization step. The process aligns the whole time series with current station site and instrument characteristics so that it can be compared to today's measurements, but it also creates substantial differences between the 2021 and 2011 normals calculations.
Read that carefully. Homogenization exists to make an old record comparable to today. That is a good goal. But the side effect is that rerunning it a decade later produces a different output than the earlier run. Your July average did not change in the sky. It changed on the page.
The additions and corrections to NCEI's holdings between 2011 and early 2021 push values the same way. A station that arrived in the holdings later can alter the regional average around it. A corrected typo in an old monthly total can nudge a season. None of it is weather.
Here is the practical implication for you. If you compare old internal benchmarks to a new normal and the new number looks off, do not assume your climate changed overnight. Ask whether the difference is climatic or non-climatic first. The two call for opposite responses. A real climatic shift changes your crew plan. A data-driven shift changes nothing about how you staff.
A quick way to tell them apart
Use three checks before you touch a schedule.
Map pattern check. Does the change follow a broad regional pattern NCEI describes? A coherent zone that is cooler and wetter, or warmer, is almost always climatic. An isolated station that looks different from every neighbor is more likely a data artifact.
Magnitude check. Changes that reach more than 2°F in parts of the Dakotas, or up to 2° warmer in the West and lee of the Rockies and Texas, are the magnitudes reported in NCEI's comparison of the two normals. Treat similar magnitudes as climatic until proven otherwise.
Source version check. If the number came from the 2011 version of holdings and you are comparing it to one from early 2021, the gap includes a known non-climatic component. Flag it as mixed before you plan around it.
If you cannot decide which force moved a value, ask your regional NCEI contact or a local climatologist. One plain question—"is this difference climatic or processing-driven?"—is enough to settle it.